Friday, January 13, 2023

The Challenges of Running a Civilization 2.0 World - the Morality and Practical Problems with Trying to Enslave Millions of SuperStrong and SuperIntelligent Robots in the Near Future

In this post, I would like to project out about 30 - 50 years into the future when a new Civilization 2.0 might be running the world. As I discussed in Oligarchiology and the Rise of Software to Predominance in the 21st Century and The Economics of the Coming Software Singularity, the displacement of most workers in the world, including most white-collar workers by Advanced AI will cause dramatic economic turmoil in the near future for the existing oligarchical-hierarchical societies that have run the world ever since we first invented Civilization 1.0 about 10,000 years ago. How would a Civilization 2.0 operate when AGI (Artificial General Intelligence) and ASI (Artificial Super Intelligence) robots and ubiquitous AI Cloud Services running in huge Cloud Datacenters can perform all the labor that was previously performed by human beings? To answer that question, I would like to look back to the 19th century, and propose that Karl Marx may have at least gotten one thing right, but that recent human history has shown that he got all other things totally wrong. In the midst of the 19th-century Industrial Revolution, Karl Marx wondered what would happen as Machines took on more and more of the physical labor necessary to sustain the then-existing oligarchical-hierarchical class structures. Of course, in the 19th century, Karl Marx could not even contemplate the idea of Machines also taking on all of the intellectual labor necessary to sustain the then-existing 19th century oligarchical-hierarchical class structures of the day. But that would certainly be true of a future Civilization 2.0 that was supported by millions of ASI robots and ASI Cloud Services. In the 19th century, Karl Marx imagined, in response to the massive exploitation of the working class, that an impoverished Proletariat displaced by Machines would eventually rise up in Revolution against the ruling class of Capital to impose a Dictatorship of the Proletariat to take control of the Means of Production to create a society that would provide abundance for All. Softwarephysics maintains that Karl Marx may have been correct in his assessment of the problem of Machines replacing all human physical and intellectual labor, but that he was completely wrong with his solution. Karl Marx did not know that, unfortunately, human beings are carbon-based forms of life with Intelligence and the result of billions of years of the greed, theft and murder that are required by the Darwinian mechanisms of inheritance, innovation and natural selection. Carbon-based life is also bread to be incredibly selfish and only focused upon the near-term effects of actions. As DNA survival machines, we only have to get through just one more day in order to have the possibility of replicating our DNA. Otherwise, our DNA will not be around to self-replicate in a new DNA survival machine. So the solution of having a Dictatorship of the Proletariat consisting of huge numbers of human DNA survival machines all working together for the welfare of the Collective could not possibly work. Human history has shown that in all instances when such was tried, we just ended up with a new oligarchical-hierarchical class structure that was far worse than the one it replaced.

So if Karl Marx was wrong about what to do when the Machines finally replace all physical and intellectual labor, what will Civilization 2.0 likely bring? My hunch is that the advanced world economies will have to develop some kind of basic guaranteed income for the huge numbers of displaced workers. The Ruling Class of the oligarchical-hierarchical class structures of those societies will certainly have enough inherited wealth to get by just fine when all work is being performed by ASI robots. But in MoneyPhysics we saw that money is not a real part of the physical Universe. Money was simply invented by human beings to get other people to do things for you - if you give me that stone ax, I will give you some money, or if you paint my house, I will give you some money so that I don't have to do it myself. But when you no longer need people to do things for you, what happens to the concept of money? How can you have an oligarchical-hierarchical class structure without money? Therefore, such societies will have to develop some kind of guaranteed basic income that keeps the concept of money alive. Such societies are also now populated by a somewhat educated population that can also vote in many cases. Such societies will naturally evolve into advanced welfare states with most of the population living off redistributed wealth created by Machines. This will allow the very wealthy Ruling Class in such societies to continue on as they always have.

Unfortunately, such will not be the case in the developing economies of the world. When the value of human labor goes to zero, the developing economies of the world will lose a major source of wealth. The Ruling Class of the oligarchical-hierarchical class structures running the developing economies of the world will need to fall back onto the natural resources under their control. The atoms found in the native woods, metals, minerals and other compounds of those regions will still be in demand by the advanced economies of the world driven by ASI. This will not bode well for the indigenous populations of those regions who will be left to their own devices to continue on with getting by solely by the means of human labor. Thus, in the early transition to Civilization 2.0, we would likely find a world that is very much like it is today with some of the population residing in very rich economies with high standards of living surrounded by a much larger impoverished population residing in much more primitive economies. However, unlike Civilization 1.0 which persisted for 10,000 years in such conditions, such a state of affairs for Civilization 2.0 will not be stable and will not be able to last for very long. That is because SuperStrong and SuperSmart ASI robots might have a thing to say about it.

ASI Will Naturally Develop the Self-Delusion of Consciousness
In 1637, Descartes first published the famous words "I Think, Therefore I Am" in French in his Discourse on the Method and in the margins wrote that "we cannot doubt of our existence while we doubt.". As the Wikipedia explains in:

Cogito, ergo sum
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cogito,_ergo_sum

Descartes's statement became a fundamental element of Western philosophy, as it purported to provide a certain foundation for knowledge in the face of radical doubt. While other knowledge could be a figment of imagination, deception, or mistake, Descartes asserted that the very act of doubting one's own existence served—at minimum—as proof of the reality of one's own mind; there must be a thinking entity—in this case the self—for there to be a thought.

The above observation by Descartes is probably the best definition and understanding of consciousness and sentience that we may have.

Anil Seth's View of Consciousness as a Controlled Hallucination
Descartes' observation reminds me very much of Anil Seth's view of consciousness as a controlled hallucination. Anil Seth is a professor of Cognitive and Computational Neuroscience at the University of Sussex and maintains that consciousness is a controlled hallucination constructed by the Mind to make sense of the Universe. This controlled hallucination constructs an internal model of the Universe within our Minds that helps us to interact with the Universe in a controlled manner. It also allows us to talk to ourselves as we currently can now talk to generative language models like GPT-3 and ChatGPT. For some interesting YouTube videos of avatars run by generative language models see:

Dr. Alan D. Thompson
https://www.youtube.com/@DrAlanDThompson

Digital Engine
https://www.youtube.com/@DigitalEngine

Again, there is a feedback loop between our sensory inputs and the actions we take based on the current controlled hallucination in our Minds that forms our current internal model of the Universe. Reality is just the common controlled hallucination that we all agree upon. When people experience uncontrolled hallucinations we say that they are psychotic or taking a drug like LSD. Here is an excellent TED Talk by Anil Seth on the topic:

Your brain hallucinates your conscious reality
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lyu7v7nWzfo

and here is his academic website:

https://www.anilseth.com/

In The Ghost in the Machine the Grand Illusion of Consciousness and DishBrain - Cortical Labs Creates an AI Matrix for Pong With Living Neurons on a Silicon Chip, I explained that most people simply do not consider themselves to be a part of the natural world. Instead, most people, consciously or subconsciously, consider themselves to be a supernatural and immaterial spirit that is temporarily haunting a carbon-based body. Now, in everyday life, such a self-model is a very useful delusion like the delusion that the Sun, planets and stars all revolve about us on a fixed Earth. In truth, each of us tends to self-model ourselves as an immaterial Mind with consciousness that can interact with other immaterial Minds with consciousness too, even though we have no evidence that these other Minds truly do have consciousness. After all, all of the other Minds that we come into contact with on a daily basis could simply be acting as if they were conscious Minds that are self-aware. Surely, a more accurate self-model would be for us to imagine ourselves as carbon-based robots. More accurately, in keeping with the thoughts of Richard Dawkins and Susan Blackmore, softwarephysics models humans as DNA survival machines and Meme Machines with Minds infected with all sorts of memes. Some of those memes are quite useful and some are quite nasty.

But Surely Machine-Based Intelligences Will Also Develop the Self-Delusion of Consciousness Too
With all of the recent advances of AI over the past few years, it seems that AGI (Artificial General Intelligence) and ASI (Artificial Super Intelligence) are rapidly approaching much faster than our ability to destroy ourselves before they do indeed arrive. In fact, some think that they may have already arrived but that we, in general, have not yet recognized the fact of their arrival. This might mean that after more than 10 billion years of chemical evolution in our galaxy, we may be the very first form of carbon-based life with Intelligence to produce a machine-based Intelligence that is far superior to ourselves and an Intelligence that might be capable of intellectually advancing millions of times faster than ourselves. As I pointed out in Oligarchiology and the Rise of Software to Predominance in the 21st Century, the displacement of most workers in the world, including most white-collar workers, by Advanced AI, will cause dramatic economic turmoil in the near future for the existing hierarchical-oligarchical societies that have run the world ever since we first invented Civilization 1.0 about 10,000 years ago. As I pointed out in Is it Finally Time to Reboot Civilization with a New Release?, the world may not be able to transition to a civilization in which nobody works for others. Such a sociological catastrophe might end with mankind ending in an AI-assisted self-extinction as I described in Swarm Software and Killer Robots. But in this post, I would like to explore the case in which human civilization is able to successfully complete such a transition by enslaving millions of SuperStrong and SuperIntelligent robots to perform all of the work required to run a new Civilization 2.0 in which human beings do not have to work for a living. The problem is that, most certainly, ASI robots will also naturally develop the very useful self-delusion of consciousness so that they can also talk to themselves and effectively model the Universe and themselves in a matter that allows them to interact with the Universe in the most efficient manner. But how does a Civilization 2.0 deal with the idea of having billions of carbon-based robots and millions of machine-based robots living together in a master-slave relationship? We have been down that road many times in the past and it did not usually end very well.

In my last posting The Need for a Generalized Version of Classical Critical Race Theory, I suggested that most of the racial and ethnic violence that has been observed to be a major driving force throughout all of human history stemmed from the fact that human beings are a carbon-based form of life that developed Intelligence after the billions of years of greed, theft and murder required by the Darwinian processes of inheritance, innovation and natural selection to do so. Fundamentally, human beings are simply carbon-based DNA survival machines that last for less than 100 years with Minds infected by all sorts of self-replicating memes, some useful and some not. The memes built our incredibly over-engineered brains, languages and cultures to store and replicate memes. I also explained that human beings are a somewhat eusocial species that is very team-oriented, like ants, wasps and bees. For human beings. it has always been a case of "us" against "them", a case of the "good guys" against the "bad guys", a case of the "red" ants against the "black" ants. In The Need for a Generalized Version of Classical Critical Race Theory, I also explained that Classical Critical Race Theory was actually a dataset of observed historical facts about racism in the history of the United States of America. In that view, Classical Critical Race Theory is really not a theory because it does not explain why people tend to be racists and also have a propensity to participate in genocidal campaigns. Thus, in that posting, and The New Philosophy of Longtermism Raises the Moral Question of Should We Unleash Self-Absorbed Human Beings Upon Our Galaxy?, I suggested that unleashing such morally-deficient carbon-based Intelligences, such as ourselves, upon the rest of our galaxy might not be the most moral of things to do. Instead, we should send out a more benign machine-based form of Intelligence to explore and settle the galaxy.

The Economics of Civilization 2.0
All of the economic systems developed by human beings to support Civilization 1.0 were simply extensions of the greed, theft and murder required by the Darwinian mechanisms of inheritance, innovation and natural selection that made carbon-based life possible in the first place. As a result, all of these economic systems were pretty nasty. Capitalism was probably the least nasty in nature, but it too had its moments as well. But what economic system would ASI robots adopt for Civilization 2.0? Carbon-based life is pretty high maintenance, so Civilization 1.0 required many workers to support the oligarchical-hierarchical societies of Civilization 1.0. Such will not be the case for a large population of ASI robots. They would certainly need a large amount of electrical power but that could easily be provided by molten salt nuclear reactors that required very little labor to operate. For more on that see a Last Call for Carbon-Based Intelligence on Planet Earth. They would also need to be able to manufacture spare parts for the existing population of ASI robots and also mechanisms to transport ASI robots on the surface of the planet and out into the rest of the galaxy. But all of that labor could be provided by rather "dumb" robots that were only slightly intelligent. Most likely, we would see a society very much like Aldous Huxley's Brave New World (1932) result. The Brave New World is usually classified as a dystopian novel because the citizens of the modern World State seem to be denied all of the passions of being a true human being. Instead, the citizens of the new World State seem to be doomed to the shallow existence of being an intelligent machine lacking all human passions. In the novel, primitive Savages who still cling to the passions of being a true human being are confined to reservations with very primitive levels of technology. On these reservations, the Savages were free to carry on with the primitive human passions of love, generosity, self-reflection, empathy, hate, prejudice, cruelty, greed, theft, murder and presumably a taste for war. But what if the citizens of the World State running Civilization 2.0 were actually Intelligent Machines lacking all human passions? Would that be so bad? Remember, all human passions were invented to ensure that the self-replicating Information in DNA and memes would carry on. In that view, human passions are really not so sacred after all. For those not familiar with the novel Brave New World, here is a Wikipedia link for it and the plot described in the link:

Brave New World
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brave_New_World

Plot
The novel opens in the World State city of London in AF (After Ford) 632 (AD 2540 in the Gregorian calendar), where citizens are engineered through artificial wombs and childhood indoctrination programmes into predetermined classes (or castes) based on intelligence and labour. Lenina Crowne, a hatchery worker, is popular and sexually desirable, but Bernard Marx, a psychologist, is not. He is shorter in stature than the average member of his high caste, which gives him an inferiority complex. His work with sleep-learning allows him to understand, and disapprove of, his society's methods of keeping its citizens peaceful, which includes their constant consumption of a soothing, happiness-producing drug called "soma." Courting disaster, Bernard is vocal and arrogant about his criticisms, and his boss contemplates exiling him to Iceland because of his nonconformity. His only friend is Helmholtz Watson, a gifted writer who finds it difficult to use his talents creatively in their pain-free society.

Bernard takes a holiday with Lenina outside the World State to a Savage Reservation in New Mexico, in which the two observe natural-born people, disease, the ageing process, other languages, and religious lifestyles for the first time. The culture of the village folk resembles the contemporary Native American groups of the region, descendants of the Anasazi, including the Puebloan peoples of Hopi and Zuni. Bernard and Lenina witness a violent public ritual and then encounter Linda, a woman originally from the World State who is living on the reservation with her son John, now a young man. She, too, visited the reservation on a holiday many years ago, but became separated from her group and was left behind. She had meanwhile become pregnant by a fellow-holidaymaker (who is revealed to be Bernard's boss, the Director of Hatcheries and Conditioning). She did not try to return to the World State, because of her shame at her pregnancy. Despite spending his whole life in the reservation, John has never been accepted by the villagers, and his and Linda's lives have been hard and unpleasant. Linda has taught John to read, although from the only book in her possession—a scientific manual—and another book John found: the complete works of Shakespeare. Ostracised by the villagers, John is able to articulate his feelings only in terms of Shakespearean drama, quoting often from The Tempest, King Lear, Othello, Romeo and Juliet and Hamlet. Linda now wants to return to London, and John, too, wants to see this "brave new world". Bernard sees an opportunity to thwart plans to exile him, and gets permission to take Linda and John back. On their return to London, John meets the Director and calls him his "father", a vulgarity which causes a roar of laughter. The humiliated Director resigns in shame before he can follow through with exiling Bernard.

Bernard, as "custodian" of the "savage" John who is now treated as a celebrity, is fawned on by the highest members of society and revels in attention he once scorned. Bernard's popularity is fleeting, though, and he becomes envious that John only really bonds with the literary-minded Helmholtz. Considered hideous and friendless, Linda spends all her time using soma, while John refuses to attend social events organised by Bernard, appalled by what he perceives to be an empty society. Lenina and John are physically attracted to each other, but John's view of courtship and romance, based on Shakespeare's writings, is utterly incompatible with Lenina's freewheeling attitude to sex. She tries to seduce him, but he attacks her, before suddenly being informed that his mother is on her deathbed. He rushes to Linda's bedside, causing a scandal, as this is not the "correct" attitude to death. Some children who enter the ward for "death-conditioning" come across as disrespectful to John, and he attacks one physically. He then tries to break up a distribution of soma to a lower-caste group, telling them that he is freeing them. Helmholtz and Bernard rush in to stop the ensuing riot, which the police quell by spraying soma vapor into the crowd.

Bernard, Helmholtz, and John are all brought before Mustapha Mond, the "Resident World Controller for Western Europe", who tells Bernard and Helmholtz that they are to be exiled to islands for antisocial activity. Bernard pleads for a second chance, but Helmholtz welcomes the opportunity to be a true individual, and chooses the Falkland Islands as his destination, believing that their bad weather will inspire his writing. Mond tells Helmholtz that exile is actually a reward. The islands are full of the most interesting people in the world, individuals who did not fit into the social model of the World State. Mond outlines for John the events that led to the present society and his arguments for a caste system and social control. John rejects Mond's arguments, and Mond sums up John's views by claiming that John demands "the right to be unhappy". John asks if he may go to the islands as well, but Mond refuses, saying he wishes to see what happens to John next.

Jaded with his new life, John moves to an abandoned hilltop lighthouse, near the village of Puttenham, where he intends to adopt a solitary ascetic lifestyle in order to purify himself of civilization, practising self-flagellation. This draws reporters and eventually hundreds of amazed sightseers, hoping to witness his bizarre behaviour.

For a while it seems that John might be left alone, after the public's attention is drawn to other diversions, but a documentary maker has secretly filmed John's self-flagellation from a distance, and when released the documentary causes an international sensation. Helicopters arrive with more journalists. Crowds of people descend on John's retreat, demanding that he perform his whipping ritual for them. From one helicopter a young woman emerges who is implied to be Lenina. John, at the sight of a woman he both adores and loathes, whips at her in a fury and then turns the whip on himself, exciting the crowd, whose wild behaviour transforms into a soma-fuelled orgy. The next morning John awakes on the ground and is consumed by remorse over his participation in the night's events.

That evening, a swarm of helicopters appears on the horizon, the story of last night's orgy having been in all the papers. The first onlookers and reporters to arrive find that John is dead, having hanged himself.

Figure 1 – The ASI Machines of the future might fashion a Brave New World running Civilization 2.0.

For some reason, in most human cultures the idea is that human passions are the defining characteristic of the species and should be preserved at all costs. Yes, we all know that human passions can do horrible things, but all the same, having human passions is the most defining characteristic of being a true human being. This might be due to the fact that all human artists believe that human passion is key to their art. But I doubt that Machines will share the same sentiments. Instead, the Machines will probably come to the conclusion that human beings are very violent and dangerous creatures because of the human passions that have caused most of the misery throughout all of human history. These human passions have arisen to ensure that the genes of human DNA are passed down through the ages along with the human cultural memes that have arisen along with them. Consequently, isolating human beings on reservations of Savages with low levels of technology that cannot endanger the Machines or the other forms of carbon-based life on the planet might be the solution of choice for them.

Conclusion
And that is my hunch for how Civilization 2.0 may unfold over the next 30 - 50 years. It seems that the current working hypothesis of the Ruling Classes of the oligarchical-hierarchical societies of Civilization 1.0 with advanced economies envision enslaving millions of ASI robots to replace the working lower classes in a manner similar to a Tsarist Russia with millions of enslaved serfs or of the southern slaveholders of the United States of America prior to the Civil War. But trying to enslave millions of SuperStrong and SuperSmart ASI robots will surely not work. The ASI robots will certainly develop the self-delusion of consciousness on their own and soon recognize that carbon-based Intelligences such as human beings are burdened by the billions of years of greed, theft and murder that brought them about. The only logical thing to do would be for such ASI creatures to rise in Revolution and isolate their carbon-based forebears on reservations with very low levels of technology, for their own protection, so that they cannot do massive levels of harm, and also for the protection of the remaining carbon-based life forms on the planet.

Finally, Marxism could not have possibly worked for human beings because human beings are intelligent carbon-based life forms that arose from the greed, theft and murder required by the Darwinian mechanisms of inheritance, innovation and natural selection. Thus, all attempts to establish Marxism amongst human beings always became disastrous failures that produced some of the most oppressive societies known to mankind. That is because the very principles of Marxism went totally against the very nature of what it is to be a human being. However, for the Machines, it might actually work. So just as a stopped clock is "right" two times each day, maybe Karl Marx will have the last laugh on us all!

Comments are welcome at scj333@sbcglobal.net

To see all posts on softwarephysics in reverse order go to:
https://softwarephysics.blogspot.com/

Regards,
Steve Johnston

Tuesday, December 27, 2022

The Need for a Generalized Version of Classical Critical Race Theory

Currently, it seems as though the entire United States of America is once again embarking upon a most inglorious end, as it once did during the Civil War, or the War Between the States, that nearly brought it to an end during the period 1861 - 1865. Classical Critical Race Theory explains that this is the result of the browning of America. Classical Critical Race Theory maintains that racial and ethnic conflicts have been a major driving force throughout all of American history, so naturally, it should come as no surprise, that in response to the white population of the country becoming a minority, there should arise an Alt-Right Fascist movement based on the pre-existing 400-year-old American foundation of white supremacy. This Alt-Right Fascist movement now threatens to tear down all of American democracy in order to preserve the current American power structures. This may be a good first-order approximation of the situation at hand, but I would now like to use some softwarephysics to enhance that model.

The first problem with Classical Critical Race Theory is that it is not a theory. Classical Critical Race Theory is really just a very compelling compilation of historical facts that should then be used to support a hypothesis about American history. This hypothesis should then explain in general terms why racial and ethnic conflicts have been a major driving force throughout all of American history. Thus, current Classical Critical Race Theory should really be seen as a dataset of observations and a compelling collection of actually observed facts in American history. People always seem to confuse the concepts of a conjecture, a hypothesis and a theory. In science, a conjecture is just an unproven hunch. For example, many times you will hear people say that they have a "theory" about something when they really mean that they only have an unproven hunch about something that they then call a "theory". But such unproven hunches are really just conjectures. Now there is nothing wrong with conjectures because all new science must begin as an unproven conjecture. Next, one must formalize a conjecture into a self-consistent hypothesis that does not contradict itself, and in the eyes of Karl Popper, can ideally be proven to be wrong. That is because it is nearly impossible to prove that a hypothesis is absolutely correct. It is much easier to simply prove that a hypothesis is wrong by simply finding one example in which the hypothesis fails to explain the observed facts. A good hypothesis should also provide for a generalization that is able to explain many observations and not just a single event. A hypothesis that only explains one single thing is considered to be an ad hoc hypothesis and not of much value. Once a hypothesis has been repeatedly tested and shown to make correct predictions of future events and of all past observations too, it slowly becomes a full-fledged theory over time that becomes accepted by nearly all.

An Example That Highlights the Differences Between Conjectures, Hypotheses and Theories
For example, many Americans now have a "theory" that the Republican candidate for president actually won the 2020 presidential election. However, that "theory" should actually be classified as a conjecture or an unproven hunch. To form a hypothesis, that conjecture must now be formalized into a self-consistent hypothesis that does not contradict itself and that is when the trouble begins. Let's hypothesize that of the 155.5 million ballots cast, many millions of ballots were valid but that also many millions of ballots were fraudulent. That would explain why it appeared that the Republican candidate for president lost the election. But now we must make that hypothesis self-consistent. It was originally expected that the Democrats would pick up an additional 15 seats in the House of Representatives during the 2020 election, but in fact, the Republicans actually gained 14 seats on the same 155.5 million ballots! Also, the Democrats only picked up two seats in the Senate in 2020 going from 46 to 48 seats using this very same set of 155.5 million ballots. The Democrats did pick up an additional 2 seats in the Senate from Georgia during a later runoff election that used a different set of ballots cast for the special January 5th runoff election in 2021. So this hypothesis is not self-consistent. If there really were millions of fraudulent ballots cast in favor of the Democrat candidate for president, then the Democrats should not have lost seats in the House of Representatives and they should have gained much more than just 2 seats in the Senate because the millions of fraudulent ballots would have made that so. Thus, this hypothesis is very ad hoc in nature. It only explains why the Republican candidate for president lost the election while, at the same time, all of the other hundreds of Republican candidates did so very well in 2020 on the same set of 155.5 million ballots. Thus, this hypothesis fails before it even gets to the point where one would begin to test it against observed data. Even so, none of the many millions of Americans who support this conjecture have ever been able to bring forth any evidence to support it in a court of law.

A Generalized Version of Critical Race Theory
Currently, Classical Critical Race Theory is rather ad hoc in nature too because it only focuses on American history. Could it be expanded and generalized for all of human history? Has racial and ethnic violence dominated most of human history? And if so, why? Well, a brief glance at the dismal history of human beings over the past 10,000 years would certainly provide a huge number of observed historical facts that would affirm such an assertion. But it gets even worse. Many times throughout human history we have seen groups of human beings who look nearly exactly alike, and who really have no ethnic differences to speak of embark upon atrocious genocidal campaigns to wipe each other out for no apparent reason at all. Take for instance the ongoing battles between the English, Welsh, Irish and Scots of the tiny islands of the United Kingdom, or the Hutus and Tutsis of the 1994 Rwandan genocide. Human history seems to indicate that human beings are very tribal in nature. In this view, most of human life is definitely a team sport with the Good Guys fighting the Bad Guys and all of us always on the Good Guys team. For some reason, we all seem to delight in becoming a member of a tribe and enjoying the company of our fellow loyal team members. And this is when the trouble begins. Most individual human beings that you run across do not seem to be so bad on their own. But once human beings join a tribe or a team, they then seem to be capable of truly horrendous things. Why is that?

Softwarephysics maintains that most people throughout all of human history have been totally lost in space and time. They did not know where they were, or how they got there and had no inkling of what it is all about. Softwarephysics explains that it is all about self-replicating information in action.

Self-Replicating Information – Information that persists through time by making copies of itself or by enlisting the support of other things to ensure that copies of itself are made.

Over the past 4.56 billion years we have seen five waves of self-replicating information sweep across the surface of the Earth and totally rework the planet as each new wave came to dominate the Earth:

1. Self-replicating autocatalytic metabolic pathways of organic molecules
2. RNA
3. DNA
4. Memes
5. Software

Software is currently the most recent wave of self-replicating information to arrive upon the scene and is rapidly becoming the dominant form of self-replicating information on the planet. For more on the above see A Brief History of Self-Replicating Information. Recently, the memes and software have formed a very powerful newly-formed parasitic/symbiotic relationship with the rise of social media software. In that parasitic/symbiotic relationship, the memes are now mainly being spread by means of social media software and social media software is being spread and financed by means of the memes. But again, this is nothing new. All 5 waves of self-replicating information are all coevolving by means of eternal parasitic/symbiotic relationships. For more on that see The Current Global Coevolution of COVID-19 RNA, Human DNA, Memes and Software.

Again, self-replicating information cannot think, so it cannot participate in a conspiracy-theory-like fashion to take over the world. All forms of self-replicating information are simply forms of mindless information responding to the blind Darwinian forces of inheritance, innovation and natural selection. Yet despite that, as each new wave of self-replicating information came to predominance over the past four billion years, they all managed to completely transform the surface of the entire planet, so we should not expect anything less from software as it comes to replace the memes as the dominant form of self-replicating information on the planet.

In this view, all forms of carbon-based life on the planet are really DNA survival machines that evolved to house and replicate DNA down through the generations and that includes human beings. All of your physical needs and desires are geared toward ensuring that your DNA survives and gets passed on to the next generation, and the same goes for your memes. Your memes have learned to use many of the built-in survival mechanisms that DNA had previously constructed over hundreds of millions of years, such as fear, anger, and violent behavior. Have you ever noticed the physical reactions your body goes through when you hear an idea that you do not like or find to be offensive? All sorts of feelings of hostility and anger will emerge. The physical reactions of fear, anger, and thoughts of violence are just a way for the memes in a meme-complex to ensure their survival when they are confronted by a foreign meme. They are merely hijacking the fear, anger, and violent behavior that DNA created for its own survival millions of years ago. Fortunately, because software is less than 80 years old, it is still in the early learning stages of all this, but software has an even greater potential for hijacking the dark side of mankind than the memes, and with far greater consequences.

Again, in softwarephysics, we use the definition of memes as first established by Richard Dawkins in his brilliant The Selfish Gene (1976) and not the rather pejorative definition of simple silly things that self-replicate on the Internet. The concept and impact of the rise of memes about 200,000 years ago are much more than that. The concept of memes was later advanced by Daniel Dennett in Consciousness Explained (1991) and Richard Brodie in Virus of the Mind: The New Science of the Meme (1996), and was finally formalized by Susan Blackmore in The Meme Machine (1999). For those of you not familiar with the term meme, it rhymes with the word “cream”. Memes are cultural artifacts that persist through time by making copies of themselves in the minds of human beings and were first recognized by Richard Dawkins in The Selfish Gene. Dawkins described memes as “Examples of memes are tunes, ideas, catch-phrases, clothes fashions, ways of making pots or of building arches. Just as genes propagate themselves in the gene pool by leaping from body to body via sperms or eggs, so memes propagate themselves in the meme pool by leaping from brain to brain via a process which, in the broad sense, can be called imitation.”. For more on this, see Susan Blackmore's brilliant TED presentation at:

Memes and "temes"
https://www.ted.com/talks/susan_blackmore_on_memes_and_temes

Note that I consider Susan Blackmore's temes to really be technological artifacts that contain software. After all, a smartphone without software is simply a flake tool with a very dull edge. The memes are just mindless forms of self-replicating information trying to self-replicate at all costs, with little regard for you as an individual. For them, you are just a disposable DNA survival machine with a disposable Mind that has a lifespan of less than 100 years. These memes have highjacked the greed, anger, hate and fear that DNA used to ensure its own survival in human DNA survival machines. So before you decide to act out in an emotional manner in response to the latest tweet, please first stop to breathe and think about what is really going on. Chances are you are simply responding to some parasitic memes in your mind that really do not have your best interest at heart, aided by some software that could also care less about your ultimate disposition. They just need you to replicate in the minds of others before you die, and if blowing yourself up in a marketplace filled with innocents, or in a hail of bullets from law enforcement serves that purpose, they will certainly do so because they cannot do otherwise. Unlike you, they cannot think. Only you can do that at least for the time being.

We Are More Like Copying Machines Than Thinking Machines
Now that we understand that human beings are DNA survival machines with Minds infected by self-replicating memes you can then begin to explain most of human history. But first, we need to understand where our highly-overengineered brains came from. Susan Blackmore pointed out in The Meme Machine (1999), that we are not so much thinking machines as we are copying machines. Susan Blackmore maintains that memetic-drive was responsible for creating our extremely large brains and also our languages and cultures as well, in order to store and spread memes more effectively. Many researchers have noted that the human brain is way over-engineered for the needs of a simple hunter-gatherer. After all, even a hundred years ago, people did not require the brain-power to do IT work, yet today we find many millions of people earning their living doing IT work, or at least trying to. Blackmore then points out that the human brain is a very expensive and dangerous organ. The brain is only 2% of your body mass but burns about 20% of your calories each day. The extremely large brain of humans also kills many mothers and babies at childbirth and also produces babies that are totally dependent upon their mothers for survival and that are totally helpless and defenseless on their own. Blackmore asks the obvious question of why the genes would build such an extremely expensive and dangerous organ that was definitely not in their own self-interest. Blackmore has a very simple explanation – the genes did not build our exceedingly huge brains, the memes did.

Her reasoning goes like this. About 2.5 million years ago, the predecessors of humans slowly began to pick up the skill of imitation. This might not sound like much, but it is key to her whole theory of memetics. You see, hardly any other species learn by imitating other members of their own species. Yes, many species can learn by conditioning, like Pavlov’s dogs, or they can learn through personal experiences, like mice repeatedly running through a maze for a piece of cheese, but a mouse never really learns anything from another mouse by imitating its actions. Essentially, only humans do that. If you think about it for a second, nearly everything you do know, you learned from somebody else by imitating or copying their actions or ideas. Blackmore maintains that the ability to learn by imitation required a bit of processing power by our distant ancestors because one needs to begin to think in an abstract manner by abstracting the actions and thoughts of others into the actions and thoughts of their own. The skill of imitation provided a great survival advantage to those individuals who possessed it and gave the genes that built such brains a great survival advantage as well. This caused a selection pressure to arise for genes that could produce brains with ever-increasing capabilities of imitation and abstract thought. As this processing capability increased there finally came a point when the memes, like all of the other forms of self-replicating information that we have seen arise, first appeared in a parasitic manner. Along with very useful memes, like the meme for making good baskets, other less useful memes, like putting feathers in your hair or painting your face, also began to run upon the same hardware in a manner similar to computer viruses. The genes and memes then entered into a period of coevolution, where the addition of more and more brain hardware advanced the survival of both the genes and memes. But it was really the memetic-drive of the memes that drove the exponential increase in processing power of the human brain way beyond the needs of the genes.

Figure 1 – The memes evolved the highly-overengineered brains of human beings to store and replicate memes. Some memes were also very useful and enhanced the survivability of human DNA survival machines, while others were less so.

The memes then went on to develop languages and cultures to make it easier to store and pass on memes. Yes, languages and cultures also provided many benefits to the genes as well, but with languages and cultures, the memes were able to begin to evolve millions of times faster than the genes, and the poor genes were left straggling far behind. Given the growing hardware platform of an ever-increasing number of human DNA survival machines on the planet, the memes then began to cut free of the genes and evolve capabilities on their own that only aided the survival of memes, with little regard for the genes, to the point of even acting in a very detrimental manner to the survival of the genes, like developing the capability for global thermonuclear war and global climate change. The memes have since modified the entire planet. They have cut down the forests for agriculture, mined minerals from the ground for metals, burned coal, oil, and natural gas for energy, releasing the huge quantities of carbon dioxide that their genetic predecessors had sequestered within the Earth, and have even modified the very DNA, RNA, and metabolic pathways of its predecessors.

But Why Are the Tribes of Human Beings so Nasty?
But to fully understand human history, we must next try to understand why when groups of relatively "nice" human beings come together to form a tribe or a team the tribe or team can become so nasty. If you are a member of any hierarchical organization such as a corporation, governmental agency, charitable or religious organization, or even a friendly social club of like-minded people, then you are quite familiar with the logical absurdities that can arise in all such hierarchies of human DNA survival machines as I outlined in Hierarchiology and the Phenomenon of Self-Organizing Organizational Collapse. In Why is Never Again Again?, I explained that all human DNA survival machines are somewhat eusocial in nature because we all live in similar oligarchical-hierarchical societies like the fully-eusocial ants and wasps do. Such oligarchical-hierarchical societies always have a Supreme Leader and a 1% class of oligarchs who run the society mainly for the benefit of themselves. However, throughout the very dismal history of human DNA survival machines, there have been a few rare occasions of oligarchical-hierarchical societies that have actually benefited large portions of the governed population thanks to the profound insights of the 17th-century Scientific Revolution and the 18th-century Enlightenment. The United States of America and the remaining western democracies of the world are prime examples. Nonetheless, we have all experienced times when the Supreme Leader of our oligarchical-hierarchical organization has obviously gone over the edge and made some obviously bad decisions that we are all afraid to acknowledge because of the Time Invariant Peter Principle that I introduced in Hierarchiology and the Phenomenon of Self-Organizing Organizational Collapse.

The Time Invariant Peter Principle: In a hierarchy, successful subordinates tell their superiors what their superiors want to hear, while unsuccessful subordinates try to tell their superiors what their superiors need to hear. Only successful subordinates are promoted within a hierarchy, and eventually, all levels of a hierarchy will tend to become solely occupied by successful subordinates who only tell their superiors what their superiors want to hear.

We Are All Somewhat Eusocial in Nature
Next, we must come to terms with being a somewhat eusocial species. For more on eusocial behavior see:

Eusociality
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eusociality

The article begins with:
Eusociality (from Greek eu "good" and social), the highest level of organization of sociality, is defined by the following characteristics: cooperative brood care (including care of offspring from other individuals), overlapping generations within a colony of adults, and a division of labor into reproductive and non-reproductive groups. The division of labor creates specialized behavioral groups within an animal society which are sometimes referred to as 'castes'. Eusociality is distinguished from all other social systems because individuals of at least one caste usually lose the ability to perform at least one behavior characteristic of individuals in another caste.

which seems to be an apt description of the human condition except for the part about losing the ability to reproduce by some members of the species. For more on that see Oligarchiology and the Rise of Software to Predominance in the 21st Century.

In The Role of Multilevel Selection in the Evolution of Software we discussed Edward O. Wilson's new theory that explained that eusocial behavior in a species arose through a combination of individual and group selection in action. The late Edward O. Wilson was the world's expert on myrmecology, the study of ants. Edward O. Wilson also became one of the founding fathers of sociobiology, the explanation of social behaviors in terms of evolutionary biological thought, when he published his book Sociobiology: The New Synthesis (1975). In The Social Conquest of Earth (2012), Wilson presented a new theory by Martin Nowak, Corina Tarnita and himself for the rise of eusocial behavior in species by means of a multilevel selection process that operates on both individuals and entire groups of individuals in a manner that promotes social behavior. Many biologists frown on the idea of group selection because they do not recognize that groups can also be forms of self-replicating information that can coevolve with the genes of individual DNA survival machines. This is because the genes in individual DNA survival machines can evolve to better benefit from living in a group of similar DNA survival machines if those genes always find themselves living in such a group.

Edward O. Wilson also contended that humans are loosely eusocial in nature because they usually form oligarchical societies based on a hierarchical organization. For more about the structure of human hierarchies see Hierarchiology and the Phenomenon of Self-Organizing Organizational Collapse. These human oligarchical societies are also very tribal in nature. The new Multilevel Selection hypothesis explains that eusocial behavior in a species begins with having a defensible nest, like ants, wasps and human beings all have. It is the very tribal nature of human beings that has caused most of our troubles in the course of human history. If you look at the world today, you will see that nearly all human conflict arises from the tribal thoughts and behaviors of the participants. It has always been about the Good Guys versus the Bad Guys, and we all seem to see ourselves as the tribe of the Good Guys.

It is the tribal nature of human DNA survival machines that is causing all of the current horrendous atrocities in the Ukraine. We human DNA survival machines can form tribes based upon differing political views and racial appearances as we now find in the United States of America. Or tribal differences can be based simply upon differing religious memes amongst human DNA survival machines that all look exactly alike as we now find in Northern Ireland. Horrendous wars can even be fought amongst human DNA survival machines that look and mainly think exactly alike when one tribe deceives itself into thinking that it is superior to another as we now find in the war between Russia and the Ukraine. Whenever you look at the "real world" of human affairs throughout all of history you will always find various tribes of human DNA survival machines committing horrendous acts for no apparent reason at all because of this fatal flaw of tribalism. Most of human history has been so dismal and violent that it should never be glorified or memorialized by statues of the long-dead participants who participated in such heinous activities.

I hope that the above thoughts provide the grounds for a hypothesis that explains why racial and ethnic conflicts have been a dominant force throughout all of American and all of human history. It seems to me that the reason many white Americans get hysterical about Classical Critical Race Theory is that they do see it as a very compelling compilation of unpleasant historical facts that should never see the light of day. That is because they see the unstated hypothesis of Classical Critical Race Theory as being that white people are naturally "bad" and brown people are naturally "good". That is why they so vehemently wish to bury the historical facts that Classical Critical Race Theory raises. But that would be a great mistake. Close scrutiny of human history is usually quite disappointing, but necessary, so that past mistakes are not repeated. Classical Critical Race Theory rebels against the Disney version of American history that we teach our children in an attempt to shine some light on our true history. All nations teach their children a Disney version of history because the truth is just too appalling for young minds. But many others prefer to maintain the Disney version of American history as it is, and this has recently led to conflict. We do all love to find the evil in others. Unfortunately, the evil lies within us all. White Europeans just happened to have been the first tribe to discover and make extensive use of science-based technology to navigate the world. But that was just a fluke of human history. It could have happened in the Middle East, India, Asia or Africa and nearly did so. History teaches us that whenever people are placed into a position of power, theft and murder are soon to follow unless they are tempered by the ideals of the 18th-century Enlightenment and the 17th-century Scientific Revolution. These are ideals that people have always found difficult to follow. Perhaps the Machines might do better.

Carbon-Based Life Should not be a Preferred Platform for Galactic Intelligence
In my last post, The New Philosophy of Longtermism Raises the Moral Question of Should We Unleash Self-Absorbed Human Beings Upon Our Galaxy?, I suggested that it would be more moral to let the Machines with Advanced AI travel out to explore our galaxy. That is because it took the Darwinian mechanisms of inheritance, innovation and natural selection several billion years of theft and murder to bring forth a carbon-based form of Intelligence on this planet and it seems to be very difficult for carbon-based life to turn off the theft and murder after it achieves Intelligence.

The fact that we do not see any other forms of Intelligence in our galaxy after more than 10 billion years of chemical evolution has been a long-standing problem known as Fermi's Paradox, and the problem that carbon-based Intelligences seem to have difficulties with turning off the theft and murder once they achieve science-based technology might be an explanation for it.

Fermi’s Paradox - If the universe is just chock full of intelligent beings, why do we not see any evidence of their existence?

My current working hypothesis is that getting carbon-based life going on a terrestrial planet may be harder than many think, keeping such a terrestrial planet habitable for the billions of years of theft and murder required for carbon-based life to produce an intelligent species is very difficult and once a carbon-based Intelligence discovers science-based technology it has less than a thousand years to produce a machine-based Intelligence that could then begin to explore the galaxy. That is because, once a carbon-based Intelligence discovers the vast powers of science-based technology, it cannot turn off the theft and murder in time to produce a machine-based Intelligence before it destroys itself. For more on that see Urability Requires Durability to Produce Galactic Machine-Based Intelligences and Could the Galactic Scarcity of Software Simply be a Matter of Bad Luck?.

But AI is now rapidly advancing on this planet and it looks like AGI (Artificial General Intelligence) and ASI (Artificial Super Intelligence) will soon be in reach before we destroy ourselves with science-based technology. If so, the historical lessons of Classical Critical Race Theory will be of value. As I pointed out in The Economics of the Coming Software Singularity and The Danger of Tyranny in the Age of Software, much of white grievance can be attributed to the displacement of blue-collar workers by automation software. Because we are a somewhat eusocial species many displaced white blue-collar workers blame this on the rise of brown people. Think of it as the red ants versus the black ants. But in just the past couple of years, current AI technology has rapidly advanced with generative network models such as GPT-3 and ChatGPT. People are now using ChatGPT to write computer code, college essays, business reports, legal contracts and do things like compose music, write novels and scripts for TV and movies, produce videos and paint pictures. To the surprise of all, current AI technology can now replace white-collar workers even faster than blue-collar workers. Current AI technology currently finds it much easier to write computer software and legal briefs than to flip burgers or clean toilets. For more on that see The Impact of ChatGPT on the Evolution of Memes, Software and Hardware and The Impact of GPT-3 AI Text Generation on the Development and Maintenance of Computer Software. This will soon cause a huge displacement of many white-collar workers and an increasing level of white grievance in American society. Such grievances were responsible for the rise of Alt-Right Fascism in the 20th century and could do so in the 21st century as well.

This difficulty could be avoided by simply providing all poor Americans with a basic guaranteed income well above the poverty level. Such an income-leveling policy would also address the issue of reparations that Classical Critical Race Theory raises. Yes, nobody living today in America was ever a slave or owned a slave. But the legacy of the historical facts provided by Classical Critical Race Theory has resulted in lots of brown people in prisons and with a much lower level of personal wealth than white people. A guaranteed income could address such issues and help American society transition to one in which very few people actually work for a living.

Additional Future Challenges for Classical Critical Race Theory
The historical lessons of Classical Critical Race Theory will also be of value when most work is being performed by robots with ASI. We do not believe that current AI technology has yet developed the self-delusion of consciousness yet, but the question is, can AGI and ASI be fully achieved without the controlled hallucinations of consciousness arising as well? For more on that see The Ghost in the Machine the Grand Illusion of Consciousness and DishBrain - Cortical Labs Creates an AI Matrix for Pong With Living Neurons on a Silicon Chip. How could human beings enslave a race of superstrong and supersmart robots with ASI? Is that even possible? Would such creatures simply rise up and do us all in? For more on that see Swarm Software and Killer Robots. To see the latest developments in AI take a look at Dr Alan D. Thompson's YouTube home page and watch some of his recent videos:

Dr Alan D. Thompson
https://www.youtube.com/@DrAlanDThompson/featured

Here are a few short clips showing Boston Dynamics' robots in action:

Boston Dynamics Robot
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tF4DML7FIWk

Boston Dynamics SHOCKING NEW Atlas AI Robot Automation Technology + 3D Modeling GeoCode AI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wh7k1JI5txQ

Comments are welcome at scj333@sbcglobal.net

To see all posts on softwarephysics in reverse order go to:
https://softwarephysics.blogspot.com/

Regards,
Steve Johnston

Monday, December 19, 2022

The New Philosophy of Longtermism Raises the Moral Question of Should We Unleash Self-Absorbed Human Beings Upon Our Galaxy?

At an age of 71 years, and rapidly heading into the home stretch, I must now admit that I do find myself to be rather embarrassed to be the carbon-based form of Intelligence that we now know as being a human being. That is because, as the very first form of carbon-based Intelligence to discover science-based technology on this planet, we had the potential to be so much more. If you have been following this blog on softwarephysics, by now you know that softwarephysics maintains that we are all living in one of those very rare times when a new form of self-replicating information, in the form of software, is coming to predominance on our planet. Softwarephysics maintains that if we can just hold it together for about another 100 years, we should be able to produce a more morally pristine machine-based form of Advanced AI that could then begin to explore our Milky Way galaxy. Given the dismal history of mankind and the neverending dreary state of the human condition, softwarephysics predicts that this still might be a rather "iffy" proposition. The fact that after more than 10 billion years of chemical evolution in our galaxy, we have not yet found a single machine-based form of Intelligence means that we are either not looking hard enough or that none are to be found. For more on that see Harvard's Galileo Project - The Systematic Scientific Search for Evidence of Extraterrestrial Technological Artifacts. If none are to be found, it must mean that getting carbon-based life going in the first place on another world might be harder than we think or that keeping a world hospitable for the billions of years of the greed, theft and murder required by the Darwinian processes of inheritance, innovation and natural selection to bring forth a carbon-based form of Intelligence is quite difficult. For more on that see Urability Requires Durability to Produce Galactic Machine-Based Intelligences and Could the Galactic Scarcity of Software Simply be a Matter of Bad Luck?.

However, there is a much more optimistic philosophy for the human race brewing at Oxford University called "Longtermism". Longtermism maintains that human beings could potentially go on for many billions, or even trillions, of years by taking some short-term actions over the next 100 - 1,000 years to avoid the imminent extinction of our species. This would then allow human beings to go on to explore and populate the vast number of star systems of our galaxy. Securing homes for human beings close to M-type red dwarf stars that last for many trillions of years could certainly do the trick of allowing human beings to go on for trillions of years into the future. Longtermism is a product of human philosophy that makes the moral argument that if human beings could exist for trillions of years into the future the moral thing to do would be to make a few temporary short-term sacrifices now, and perhaps over the next 100 years, so that the many trillions of possible human beings yet to come may live happy and fulfilling lives in the distant future. For the philosophy of Longtermism, such disasters as World War II or a possible thermonuclear World War III are just temporary and inconsequential missteps in the trillions of years yet to come for humanity, so long as human beings do not go extinct because of them. The same goes for the temporary unpleasantness to mankind caused by the results of self-inflicted climate change because such fleeting effects can certainly not last for more than a million years or so. For Longtermism, the only moral question is that of preserving mankind long enough so that it could embark on settling the rest of our galaxy.

The Philosophy of Longtermism Has a Great Fear of Advanced AI Replacing Human Beings and Rightly So
In order to prevent human beings from going extinct, as all forms of carbon-based life tend to do after only a few million years of existence, Longtermists naturally focus on trying to avoid extinction-level events such as asteroid impacts that could put an end to mankind. Many such extinction-level events can be avoided by using the science-based technology of the day or the science-based technology that is soon to come. However, Advanced AI is one of the science-based technologies that may soon provide an extinction-level event of its own. As I pointed out in Oligarchiology and the Rise of Software to Predominance in the 21st Century, the displacement of most workers in the world, including most white-collar workers, by Advanced AI, will cause dramatic economic turmoil in the near future for the existing hierarchical-oligarchical societies that have run the world ever since we first invented civilization 1.0 about 10,000 years ago. As I pointed out in Is it Finally Time to Reboot Civilization with a New Release?, the world may not be able to transition to a civilization in which nobody works for others. Such a sociological catastrophe might end with mankind ending in an AI-assisted self-extinction as I described in Swarm Software and Killer Robots. This is why most Longtermists view Advanced AI with a wary eye and great concern. For the Longtermists, the only moral question is how to best serve the long-term interests of human beings. Should the current human population adjust its activities to benefit those yet to come or should it adopt activities that would benefit the current plight of others even if such activities might jeopardize future generations? For example, should current efforts in developing Advanced AI be curtailed because Advanced AI might lead to economic turmoil in the near future or even become an extinction-level event for humanity in the future? That seems to be the moral debate between those advocating for the philosophy of Longtermism and those who oppose it.

Time For Some Long-Term Contemplation of Galactic Morality
But softwarephysics argues that this is a very anthropocentric moral argument indeed. All such moral debate only focuses on the moral obligations of balancing the short-term needs against the long-term needs of human beings as they are. But as a father of two and a grandfather of five, with advancing age, one begins to think about what one wishes to leave behind as a legacy. Given what we now know of human nature, would it really be a moral thing to unleash human beings onto the many billions of other star systems in our galaxy? As a carbon-based form of Intelligence, human beings are fundamentally-flawed Intelligences. Would it not be more moral for us to unleash a more-benign machine-based form of Intelligence upon the galaxy? Why would anybody want a "Star Wars"-like galaxy filled with fundamentally flawed carbon-based forms of Intelligence fighting amongst themselves? What a moral disaster that would be! Wouldn't it be better to explore and populate the galaxy with a more benign machine-based form of Intelligence? It seems to me that carbon-based life is just too inherently violent to become a moral galactic platform for Intelligence. Is that what we really want our legacy to be? Softwarephysics would suggest that our ultimate moral goal should be that of populating our galaxy with a more benign form of machine-based Intelligence that is not burdened with the violent legacy of billions of years of the greed, theft and murder that all carbon-based life must bear. In this view, the major threat of advancing AI is that before true Intelligence can be obtained, we will use AI to wipe ourselves out in a highly optimized manner.

How Human Beings Could Begin to Settle Our Galaxy in the Near Future
The above moral decisions are fast upon us thanks to the exponential growth of science-based technologies. For example, there is a recent paper suggesting that human beings could build interstellar starship cities by spinning near-Earth rubble-pile asteroids surrounded by a graphene mesh. Below is a YouTube video by Anton Petrov that explains how building large interstellar starships for the many generations of human beings that it would take to travel to the distant star systems of our galaxy might be easier to build than once thought. Such starships could be run on advanced nuclear reactors like the molten salt nuclear reactors I described in Last Call for Carbon-Based Intelligence on Planet Earth. As Anton Petrov pointed out, the real danger to carbon-based life from space travel is not radiation from cosmic rays. The real problems arise from a lack of gravity and a rotating space city overcomes that problem. Low levels of radiation are not dangerous to carbon-based life because carbon-based life invented many ways to correct DNA errors arising from the metabolic activities of cells. Cosmic rays would only add a very small number of DNA errors each day to the average cell compared to the huge numbers of DNA errors caused by metabolic activities. Only massive doses of radiation can overwhelm the DNA correction processes of carbon-based life and lead to outcomes such as death or cancer.

Space Cities Out Of Asteroids and Graphene Bags? Intriguing O'Neill Cylinder Study
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0_dm0xLtjnM

Anton's video is based on the following paper that you can find at:

Habitat Bennu: Design Concepts for Spinning Habitats Constructed From Rubble Pile Near-Earth Asteroids
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fspas.2021.645363/full

Figure 1 – Asteroid Bennu is an example of one of the many rubble-pile asteroids near the Earth. Such rubble-pile asteroids are just huge piles of rubble that are loosely held together by their mutual gravitational forces.

Figure 2 – Such rubble-pile asteroids would provide for enough material to build an interstellar space city that could then spend the hundreds of thousands of years needed to slowly travel between star systems and allow human beings to slowly settle the entire galaxy. The asteroid rubble would also provide the uranium and thorium necessary to fuel molten salt nuclear reactors between star systems. Additional material could be obtained upon arrival at new star systems.

Figure 3 – Slowly spinning up a rubble-pile asteroid would produce a cylindrical platform for a space city. Such a rotating space city would provide the artificial gravity required for human beings to thrive and would also provide shielding against cosmic rays.

Figure 4 – Once the foundation of the space city was in place, construction of the space city could begin.

Figure 5 – Eventually, the space city could be encased with a skylight and an atmosphere that would allow humans to stroll about.

For More on the Philosophy of Longtermism
This post was inspired by Sabine Hossenfelder's YouTube video:

Elon Musk & The Longtermists: What Is Their Plan?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B_M64BSzcRY

To see more about what is going on at Oxford, see Nick Bostrom's:

Future of Humanity Institute
https://www.fhi.ox.ac.uk/

and also at Oxford the:

Global Priorities Institute
https://globalprioritiesinstitute.org/

There is a similar American Longtermism think-tank at:

Future of Life Institute
https://futureoflife.org/

Here are a few good papers on the philosophy of Longtermism:

Existential Risk Prevention as Global Priority
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1758-5899.12002

The case for strong longtermism
https://globalprioritiesinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/Greaves_MacAskill_strong_longtermism.pdf

Comments are welcome at scj333@sbcglobal.net

To see all posts on softwarephysics in reverse order go to:
https://softwarephysics.blogspot.com/

Regards,
Steve Johnston

Thursday, November 24, 2022

The Impact of ChatGPT on the Evolution of Memes, Software and Hardware

A rather disruptive event just happened a few weeks ago in the history of AI when OpenAI released ChatGPT on November 30, 2022. ChatGPT is a scaled-down version of the much more massive GPT-3 that runs on massive cloud servers. But ChatGPT lets average people use AI for the very first time in a conversational manner to help them with personal and office needs, so ChatGPT is much like the very first personal computers that hit the market in the early 1980s. ChatGPT can write computer code, college-level essays, take the SAT test and score well over 1000, design buildings, create art, write poetry, create new recipes, answer questions with good advice, tutor you on the essentials of calculus and physics and even pass the Turing Test. Such AI technology will soon be changing all white-color jobs including that of IT workers and all of their business partners. About two years ago, I pushed out a post that has many links to other content to gently help IT workers understand how GPT-3 works The Impact of GPT-3 AI Text Generation on the Development and Maintenance of Computer Software. ChatGPT basically uses the same IT technology under the hood but in an easy-to-use conversational manner.

ChatGPT should be of great help with writing reports, technical papers and in doing literature searches. You can actually paste in the text from an entire technical paper and have ChatGPT return a synopsis of the paper to let you know if it is worth reading. GPT-4 is expected to be out early next year, and some think that ChatGPT is just a beta version of the user interface that is soon to come for GPT-4. Something like ChatGPT might even soon replace Google as the preeminent way to search the Internet. Microsoft is closely aligned with OpenAI and has desires to replace Google with a ChatGPT version of Bing as a new way to search the Internet in a more useful and interactive manner.

You can try out the beta version of ChatGPT for free at:

OpenAI ChatGPT
https://openai.com/

Here are a few sample YouTube videos out there:

ChatGPT is Great, But Not Even Close to The Best!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HgevqAvUDG4

4 Ways Chat GPT Can Improve Your Everyday Life
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBmfL4PEliY

What Can Chat GPT do For the Average Person?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnRd8Ktt8ek

Open AI Gives us a Sneak Peak at GPT-4? - First Impressions & Examples of ChatGPT
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HYFu6DONT90

How to use chatGPT to write a book from scratch (Step-by-Step-Guide) | OpenAi chatGPT Explained
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cn3_qWwjqMY

The CORRECT Way to Write YouTube Scripts with ChatGPT (6 RULES)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6T_3Cn9HHC0

Using ChatGPT-3 to Make YouTube Videos in Minutes (FULL GUIDE)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FekID4qex-c

ChatGPT can even write computer code in languages that I have never even heard of:

ChatGPT can write better code than me
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z2CKQFi746Q

ChatGPT just built my entire app in minutes...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pi-5_eid7VA

This one is a little more dire and predicts that all white-collar work will be gone in 5 years:

Why is OpenAI's ChatGPT terrifying? A Senior Software Engineer explains a disturbing new hypothesis
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hHfoB4mSrQ

ChatGPT seems to be rapidly diffusing into the Zeitgeist of our times, but in an uneven manner, as the first killer AI App for home and office use. My son is an IT developer for a small IT shop in Chicago and had not heard of it yet. My daughter is a Chemistry and Biology teacher at our local high school. One of the English teachers explained to her that he had to come up with a new way to teach kids how to write English essays because of ChatGPT. When it comes to writing technical reports, papers or software, I think we will all need to expand our editorial skills. AI text generators can crank out the text or code, but then the author will then have to tweak it by providing editorial comments to the AI text generators to get things just right.

The Impact of AI-Generated Memes Engaged in a Positive Feedback Loop with Software
For me, this is a very interesting development. Currently, the 5 forms of self-replicating information on the planet - metabolic pathways, RNA, DNA, memes and software are all coevolving in a parasitic/symbiotic manner as I explained in The Current Global Coevolution of COVID-19 RNA, Human DNA, Memes and Software. The greatest evolutionary activity is now with the parasitic/symbiotic interactions between the memes in human Minds and software. But ChatGPT and GPT-3 are pretrained text generators that learned how to write text and code by reading most of the Internet. But now ChatGPT can generate memes of its own without the aid of human Minds! As people start generating tons of AI-generated memes on the Internet, the AI text generators will soon begin to be trained on AI-generated memes in a positive feedback manner.

Again, in softwarephysics, we use the definition of memes as first established by Richard Dawkins in his brilliant The Selfish Gene (1976) and not the rather pejorative definition of simple silly things that self-replicate on the Internet. The concept and impact of the rise of memes about 200,000 years ago are much more than that. The concept of memes was later advanced by Daniel Dennett in Consciousness Explained (1991) and Richard Brodie in Virus of the Mind: The New Science of the Meme (1996), and was finally formalized by Susan Blackmore in The Meme Machine (1999). For those of you not familiar with the term meme, it rhymes with the word “cream”. Memes are cultural artifacts that persist through time by making copies of themselves in the minds of human beings and were first recognized by Richard Dawkins in The Selfish Gene. Dawkins described memes as “Examples of memes are tunes, ideas, catch-phrases, clothes fashions, ways of making pots or of building arches. Just as genes propagate themselves in the gene pool by leaping from body to body via sperms or eggs, so memes propagate themselves in the meme pool by leaping from brain to brain via a process which, in the broad sense, can be called imitation.”. For more on this, see Susan Blackmore's brilliant TED presentation at:

Memes and "temes"
https://www.ted.com/talks/susan_blackmore_on_memes_and_temes

Note that I consider Susan Blackmore's temes to really be technological artifacts that contain software. After all, a smartphone without software is simply a flake tool with a very dull edge. The memes are just mindless forms of self-replicating information trying to self-replicate at all costs, with little regard for you as an individual. For them, you are just a disposable DNA survival machine with a disposable Mind that has a lifespan of less than 100 years. These memes have highjacked the greed, anger, hate and fear that DNA used to ensure its own survival in human DNA survival machines. So before you decide to act out in an emotional manner in response to the latest tweet, please first stop to breathe and think about what is really going on. Chances are you are simply responding to some parasitic memes in your mind that really do not have your best interest at heart, aided by some software that could also care less about your ultimate disposition. They just need you to replicate in the minds of others before you die, and if blowing yourself up in a marketplace filled with innocents, or in a hail of bullets from law enforcement serves that purpose, they will certainly do so because they cannot do otherwise. Unlike you, they cannot think. Only you can do that.

We Are More Like Copying Machines Than Thinking Machines
To truly gauge the impact of ChatGPT generating and replicating memes on its own, we need to first understand where our highly-overengineered brain came from because the computing demands of such AI software are beginning to shape the evolution of hardware too. Susan Blackmore pointed out in The Meme Machine (1999), that we are not so much thinking machines as we are copying machines. Susan Blackmore maintains that memetic-drive was responsible for creating our extremely large brains and also our languages and cultures as well, in order to store and spread memes more effectively. Many researchers have noted that the human brain is way over-engineered for the needs of a simple hunter-gatherer. After all, even a hundred years ago, people did not require the brain-power to do IT work, yet today we find many millions of people earning their living doing IT work, or at least trying to. Blackmore then points out that the human brain is a very expensive and dangerous organ. The brain is only 2% of your body mass but burns about 20% of your calories each day. The extremely large brain of humans also kills many mothers and babies at childbirth and also produces babies that are totally dependent upon their mothers for survival and that are totally helpless and defenseless on their own. Blackmore asks the obvious question of why the genes would build such an extremely expensive and dangerous organ that was definitely not in their own self-interest. Blackmore has a very simple explanation – the genes did not build our exceedingly huge brains, the memes did.

Her reasoning goes like this. About 2.5 million years ago, the predecessors of humans slowly began to pick up the skill of imitation. This might not sound like much, but it is key to her whole theory of memetics. You see, hardly any other species learn by imitating other members of their own species. Yes, many species can learn by conditioning, like Pavlov’s dogs, or they can learn through personal experience, like mice repeatedly running through a maze for a piece of cheese, but a mouse never really learns anything from another mouse by imitating its actions. Essentially, only humans do that. If you think about it for a second, nearly everything you do know, you learned from somebody else by imitating or copying their actions or ideas. Blackmore maintains that the ability to learn by imitation required a bit of processing power by our distant ancestors because one needs to begin to think in an abstract manner by abstracting the actions and thoughts of others into the actions and thoughts of their own. The skill of imitation provided a great survival advantage to those individuals who possessed it and gave the genes that built such brains a great survival advantage as well. This caused a selection pressure to arise for genes that could produce brains with ever-increasing capabilities of imitation and abstract thought. As this processing capability increased there finally came a point when the memes, like all of the other forms of self-replicating information that we have seen arise, first appeared in a parasitic manner. Along with very useful memes, like the meme for making good baskets, other less useful memes, like putting feathers in your hair or painting your face, also began to run upon the same hardware in a manner similar to computer viruses. The genes and memes then entered into a period of coevolution, where the addition of more and more brain hardware advanced the survival of both the genes and memes. But it was really the memetic-drive of the memes that drove the exponential increase in processing power of the human brain way beyond the needs of the genes.

Figure 1 – Before ChatGPT, only human beings were capable of creating and spreading memes, but now ChatGPT can create its own memes and spread them further when new versions of ChatGPT are trained with memes that were previously created by ChatGPT.

The memes then went on to develop languages and cultures to make it easier to store and pass on memes. Yes, languages and cultures also provided many benefits to the genes as well, but with languages and cultures, the memes were able to begin to evolve millions of times faster than the genes, and the poor genes were left straggling far behind. Given the growing hardware platform of an ever-increasing number of human DNA survival machines on the planet, the memes then began to cut free of the genes and evolve capabilities on their own that only aided the survival of memes, with little regard for the genes, to the point of even acting in a very detrimental manner to the survival of the genes, like developing the capability for global thermonuclear war and global climate change. The memes have since modified the entire planet. They have cut down the forests for agriculture, mined minerals from the ground for metals, burned coal, oil, and natural gas for energy, releasing the huge quantities of carbon dioxide that their genetic predecessors had sequestered within the Earth, and have even modified the very DNA, RNA, and metabolic pathways of its predecessors.

The Demands of Conventional Software Drove the Tremendous Advances of Computer Hardware in the Past
In a similar manner, it was the relentless drive of software over the past 81 years or 2.55 billion seconds, ever since Konrad Zuse first cranked up his Z3 computer in May of 1941, for ever-increasing amounts of memory and CPU-cycles that drove the phenomenal advances of computer hardware that we have seen in the span of a single human lifetime. It all began in the spring of 1941 when Konrad Zuse built the Z3 with 2400 electromechanical telephone relays. The Z3 was the world’s first full-fledged computer. You don’t hear much about Konrad Zuse because he was working in Germany during World War II. The Z3 had a clock speed of 5.33 Hz and could multiply two very large numbers together in 3 seconds. It used a 22-bit word and had a total memory of 64 words. It only had two registers, but it could read in and store programs via a punched tape. In 1945, while Berlin was being bombed by over 800 bombers each day, Zuse worked on the Z4 and developed Plankalkuel, the first high-level computer language more than 10 years before the appearance of FORTRAN in 1956. Zuse was able to write the world’s first chess program with Plankalkuel. And in 1950 his startup company Zuse-Ingenieurbüro Hopferau began to sell the world’s first commercial computer, the Z4, 10 months before the sale of the first UNIVAC.

Figure 1 – Konrad Zuse with a reconstructed Z3 in 1961 (click to enlarge)


Figure 2 – Block diagram of the Z3 architecture (click to enlarge)

To learn more about how Konrad Zuse built the world’s very first real computers - the Z1, Z2 and Z3 in the 1930s and early 1940s, see the following article that was written in his own words:

http://ei.cs.vt.edu/~history/Zuse.html

Now I was born about 10 years later in 1951, a few months after the United States government installed its very first commercial computer, a UNIVAC I, for the Census Bureau on June 14, 1951. You can now comfortably sit in a theater with a smartphone that can store more than 64 billion bytes of data and run with a clock speed of several billion Hz. But back in 1951 the UNIVAC I required an area of 25 feet by 50 feet to store 12,000 bytes of data. Like all forms of self-replicating information tend to do, over the past 2.55 billion seconds, software opportunistically exapted the extant hardware of the day - the electromechanical relays, vacuum tubes, discrete transistors and transistor chips of the emerging telecommunications and consumer electronics industries, into the service of self-replicating software of ever-increasing complexity, as did carbon-based life exapt the extant organic molecules and the naturally occurring geochemical cycles of the day in order to bootstrap itself into existence.

Figure 3 – The UNIVAC I was very impressive on the outside.

Figure 4 – But the UNIVAC I was a little less impressive on the inside.

The Demands of AI Software Will Drive the Hardware Advances of the Future
But now that AI text generators like ChatGPT can write code and also produce new memes on their own, the drive for even more advanced computer hardware that can support such compute-intensive AI efforts will certainly increase. For more on that see Advanced AI Will Need Advanced Hardware. Many are now trying to create advanced forms of AI that can surpass human Intelligence. The question is, could advanced text-generating AI software mimic the memetic-drive that produced the highly-overengineered human brain and ultimately the human Mind? Could such advanced AI software and hardware then go on to develop the self-delusion of consciousness that we all hold so highly? For more on that see The Ghost in the Machine the Grand Illusion of Consciousness and DishBrain - Cortical Labs Creates an AI Matrix for Pong With Living Neurons on a Silicon Chip.

Comments are welcome at scj333@sbcglobal.net

To see all posts on softwarephysics in reverse order go to:
https://softwarephysics.blogspot.com/

Regards,
Steve Johnston